How we picked
The chamoisis the product — everything else is fabric around it. We favored pads described with real structure (multi-density or gel inserts shaped for the sit bones) over undifferentiated foam, since a flat foam slab compresses and stops working. Then the cut: leg grippers that hold without cutting off circulation, and a waist or strap system that does not pinch. Then fit specificity, which is why a women’s-cut pad earns its own slot rather than being an afterthought. We have not worn each of these for a season; here is exactly what we do instead.
Shorts vs bibs, honestly
Shortswin on convenience: easy on and off, no straps, and you can wear them under regular clothes without looking like you are in costume. The failure mode is the waistband — it presses into your stomach when you lean forward, and on long rides it can roll or slide, taking the pad’s position with it. Bibs fix both problems by hanging the shorts from your shoulders: no waist pressure, and the pad stays exactly where it was designed to sit. They are warmer, they cost a little more, and they make bathroom stops a production. For rides under an hour, shorts are fine. Past that, most riders prefer bibs.
The two rules that make padded shorts work
No underwear. This is the one everybody gets wrong. The chamois is designed to sit against your skin; underwear underneath adds seams and holds moisture, which is precisely the recipe for the chafing the shorts exist to prevent. Do not re-wear them.A chamois worn twice is a chafing and infection risk — wash after every ride, which is the real argument for owning two pairs. Combine either pick with an appropriate saddle rather than the widest, softest one you can find, and most saddle discomfort simply stops being a topic.